Photo Credits
Fanfotography.com Danny Low
SF Chronicle Paul Chinn
SF Chronicle John Blanchard

Whistling Wings and Pintail Duck Clubs (Area 4, Newark)

What:  The City of Newark is reviewing a development proposal that would build an 18-hole championship golf course and executive housing on a large portion of these lands. 

Two alternatives were proposed during a community workshop held at the end of 2007.

Alternative A

Alternative B

During the February 6, 2008 presentation to the Planning Commission the maps were presented with a few alterations.  The conceptual development plan has been split into four maps - two alternatives for Area 3 (the area surrounded by existing development east of the railroad tracks - the railroad tracks are along the eastern edge of Area 4):

Alternative 3A

Alternative 3B

and two alternatives for Area 4 (the undeveloped area west of the railroad tracks) :

Alternative 4A

Alternative 4B

What's At Stake:

  • Ducks and shorebirds inhabit the areas of ponded waters during the rainy season, and portions of the land support the endangered salt marsh harvest mouse.  Over the levee in the tidal marshes along Mowry Slough the endangered California clapper rail can be found and harbor seals have an important haul-out area.
  • Most of the area identified as Area 4 was included in the congressionally approved refuge expansion boundary mapo of 1990.
  • Extremely few places remain along the edges of the bay where the gradient from tidal marsh to upland habitats can be restored.
  • Area 4 is one of the few places where this important transition zone could be recovered, and without tremendous effort.
  • Under the heading, "Unique Restoration Opportunities," the Goals Project states,"There are opportunities to restore historic tidal marsh/upland

transitional habitat..." and under "Recommendations," "Protect and enhance the tidal marsh/upland transition at the upper end of Mowry Slough..."

In addition to the numerous environmental issues, there are public safety issues: flood and seismic concerns, emergency response time, limited access to the proposed development, etc., as well as sea-level rise concerns.  The BCDC sea-level rise map shows the majority of the site inundated by a one meter rise in sea-level.

What You Can Do:

  • Consultants for the City of Newark are currently working on the draft environmental impact report (DEIR) for the proposed development project.  The city expects the DEIR to be circulated in September 2008 (click here for the current timeline).
  • CCCR submitted comments during the public scoping period that can be viewed here.
  • If you wish to be notified when the DEIR is released please contact Terrence Grindall at Terrence.Grindall@newark.org
  • Check our website for updates and notification about upcoming meetings or comment periods.

 

 

Home    About us    Meetings    Take Action    Newsletter    Links    Contact
© 2007 Citizens Committeee to Complete the Refuge

design by RPMC